Trending
Methodology

How we review games.

Every review answers two questions. Should an operator put this game in front of players? And is it a fair, well-made game for the people who play it? We score both, show our working and give one verdict.

  • 8 criteria
  • 2 lenses: operator and player
  • 5 verdicts
  • 2 editors on every score

Four principles

They decide every call we make, from what we test to which verdict we give.

1Hands-on, not press-releaseWe play every game we review, on desktop and on mobile. A studio deck tells us what a game is meant to do. Play tells us what it does.
2Two lenses, one reviewOperators need to know if a game earns its lobby slot. Players need to know if it is fair and fun. A game that fails players is not a good commercial bet either.
3Only numbers we can checkRTP, max win and volatility come from certified documents or the game rules. Anything we cannot verify appears in square brackets until we can.
4Scores are not for saleNo studio sees a score or a verdict before we publish. Paid formats exist, they are labelled, and they never carry a score.

The process, step by step

Seven steps from the moment a game reaches the desk to the moment the review goes live, and after.

  1. Intake

    The studio sends a demo link, the game sheet, the rules, the certified RTP list and the target markets. We log the release in our review tracker with its type and volatility band.

  2. Hands-on testing

    At least three separate sessions on two devices, desktop and mobile portrait. A minimum of 500 base-game spins across two stake levels, and every bonus route triggered or bought where the demo allows. We note pacing, dead spells, feature frequency and anything that confuses.

  3. Verification

    Every figure in the At a glance box is checked against the rules, the paytable or the certification documents. If a figure cannot be verified, it is published as a placeholder, for example [RTP to confirm], never as a guess.

  4. Category benchmark

    We compare the game with at least three recent releases of the same type and volatility band. Lobby appeal and feature depth are always judged against what operators already list, not in a vacuum.

  5. Scoring and calibration

    The reviewer scores all eight criteria with a written reason for each. A second editor reviews the scores. Where the two differ by more than one point on any criterion, they talk it through and the reason for the final score is recorded.

  6. Fact check with the studio

    The studio sees the At a glance specifications only, to correct factual errors. It does not see the copy, the scores or the verdict before publication.

  7. Publish and revisit

    The review goes live with its score, verdict and date. Worth watching verdicts are revisited after 90 days. Every later change is logged at the foot of the review.

What we cannot measure. We test in demo mode, so we do not see real-money player behaviour or a game's live performance in any lobby. Demo results are not predictive of any individual session. Where an operator or studio shares performance data with us, we say so and explain how we used it.

The scorecard

Eight criteria, each scored from 1 to 5. Four belong to the operator lens and carry 60% of the overall score. Four belong to the player lens and carry 40%.

Operator lens · 60%Player lens · 40%
Operator lens15% of the score

Feature depth

Does the game give players a reason to stay past the first session?

What we checkHow bonus rounds trigger and build, how many routes there are, whether the base game holds interest between features.
5
Features that evolve through a session and change the decisions players make.
1
A single free-spins round reskinned from a dozen other games.
Operator lens15% of the score

Lobby appeal

Will it stand out in a crowded lobby?

What we checkThumbnail legibility at small sizes, clarity of theme, distinctiveness against similar titles, any brand or IP pull.
5
Instantly readable as a tile and unlike anything already listed in its category.
1
Interchangeable with dozens of titles already in every lobby.
Operator lens15% of the score

Market flexibility

How easily can it be listed in regulated markets?

What we checkRTP variants, bonus buy on and off, certified jurisdictions, localisation, currency and stake configuration.
5
Several RTP configurations, optional bonus buy and certification in major regulated markets.
1
One fixed configuration and very limited certification.
Operator lens15% of the score

Retention potential

Does it fit the audience a lobby actually serves?

What we checkVolatility against the target audience, pacing, how often wins land, and whether the max win is credible.
5
A clear audience fit, with pacing that brings players back.
1
Long dead spells for a casual audience, or too flat for high-volatility fans.
Player lens10% of the score

Gameplay and pacing

Is it fun to play, spin after spin?

What we checkSpin speed, length of animations, clarity of what just happened, sound and the feel of the feature.
5
Crisp, readable and satisfying, with features that feel earned.
1
Slow, noisy or confusing. Wins are hard to follow.
Player lens10% of the score

Transparency

Can a player understand what they are playing?

What we checkRTP shown in game, clear rules and paytable, bonus buy price explained, max win stated with its conditions.
5
Everything a player needs is one tap away and in plain language.
1
RTP hidden, rules vague, the cost of features unclear.
Player lens10% of the score

Accessibility

Can everyone play it comfortably?

What we checkMobile portrait play, readable text, colour contrast, sound off by choice, a minimum stake that suits casual play.
5
Plays perfectly on a phone in one hand, with readable text and sensible stakes.
1
Desktop-first layout, tiny text, colour alone carrying meaning.
Player lens10% of the score

Safer play design

Does the design respect the player?

What we checkNo near-miss theatrics, no celebrating wins smaller than the stake, clear session information where markets require it, honest bonus buy framing.
5
Celebrates real wins only and keeps players informed.
1
Losses dressed up as wins and pressure to keep spinning.

How the overall score works. The operator lens average counts for 60% and the player lens average for 40%. The result is rounded to the nearest half point and shown out of 5. The verdict then follows the rules below, including the safety gates, which can override a high total.

Try the scoring

Set a score for each criterion and see the overall score and verdict the rules produce. This is the same calculation our editors use.

Feature depthOperator lens · 15%
Lobby appealOperator lens · 15%
Market flexibilityOperator lens · 15%
Retention potentialOperator lens · 15%
Gameplay and pacingPlayer lens · 10%
TransparencyPlayer lens · 10%
AccessibilityPlayer lens · 10%
Safer play designPlayer lens · 10%
Result
4/5
Operator lens3.8
Player lens3.8
Recommended

A strong fit for most lobbies with no gate triggered.

How we award verdicts

The score sets the starting point. The rules below decide the label, checked in this order.

With caveats
Safety gates first

Any criterion scored 1, or Safer play design scored 2 or lower, means With caveats whatever the total. An overall score below 3 also lands here. The review explains what needs fixing.

Niche appeal
Strong, but narrow

Overall 3.5 or higher with Market flexibility at 2 or lower. A well-made game that only works for one market or audience.

Editor's pick
The best of the month

Overall 4.5 or higher with no criterion below 4. Qualifying is not enough: the desk chooses at most one Editor’s pick a month, and it must beat that month’s other releases.

Recommended
A strong fit for most lobbies

Overall 3.75 or higher with no gate triggered. Includes games that qualify for Editor’s pick but were not chosen.

Worth watching
Promising, not proven

Overall from 3 to below 3.75. Also used for a strong debut from a new studio with no track record. Revisited after 90 days.

Reading a review

The same review serves two readers. Pick yours.

If you run or stock a lobby

Use the review as a listing brief. Each part answers a question you would ask a studio account manager.

  • At a glanceStudio, type, release date, RTP variants, volatility, max win, bet range and bonus buy. Everything you need to check fit with your licence and your audience.
  • The operator lens scoreFeature depth, lobby appeal, market flexibility and retention potential. Scored separately so you can weigh what matters to your lobby.
  • Who it suitsThe player segments and markets we think the game serves best, and where it will struggle.
  • Watch-outsCompliance, configuration and design issues to check before listing, such as missing certifications or bonus buy restrictions.
  • Studio contextWhere the game sits in the studio’s roadmap and how it compares with the studio’s recent releases.
For studios and operatorsWant your game reviewed?

Send the demo link, game sheet, rules, certified RTP list and target markets to news@igamingrepublic.com. Editorial reviews are free and never guaranteed.

Independence and disclosure

We are a trade publication that also sells media. These rules keep the two apart.

No previews of scoresStudios fact-check specifications only. Copy, scores and verdicts are never shared before publication.
Paid formats are labelledProduct spotlights and other paid content carry a Sponsored label and never include a score or a verdict.
Advertising buys nothing hereWhether a studio advertises with us has no bearing on whether we review its games or how we score them.
Commercial links are labelledIf a review ever carries a commercial link, it says so next to the link.
We say how we playedEach review states the build, the devices and the date we tested, so readers know what our verdict is based on.
Conflicts are declaredIf anyone on the desk has a working relationship with the studio, we say so at the top of the review or hand it to another editor.

Updates and corrections

Games change after launch. Reviews change with them, in the open.

We re-test whenThe RTP configuration, rules, bonus buy or maximum win change, or the game is certified in a major new market.
We revisit after 90 daysEvery Worth watching verdict, to see whether the promise held. The verdict can move up, down or stay.
We log every changeThe foot of each review lists what changed, when and why, including any change to the score or verdict.
Spotted an error?Email hello@igamingrepublic.com. Our corrections policy sets out how we respond.
Want your game reviewed?Send the demo link, game sheet, rules, certified RTP list and target markets. Editorial reviews are free and never guaranteed. For guaranteed coverage, ask about a labelled Product spotlight.

Stay informed with Headlines

Our weekly briefing for industry leaders who want fast, accurate and relevant iGaming intelligence. Every Monday morning.

Search the Republic

Press Enter to see all results. Esc closes.

Choose what we may use. You can change this at any time from “Cookie settings”. More in our privacy policy.

Cookie categories

Get the media kit

Leave your email and we’ll send you the media kit within 24 hours.