Feature depth
Does the game give players a reason to stay past the first session?
- 5
- Features that evolve through a session and change the decisions players make.
- 1
- A single free-spins round reskinned from a dozen other games.
Every review answers two questions. Should an operator put this game in front of players? And is it a fair, well-made game for the people who play it? We score both, show our working and give one verdict.
They decide every call we make, from what we test to which verdict we give.
Seven steps from the moment a game reaches the desk to the moment the review goes live, and after.
The studio sends a demo link, the game sheet, the rules, the certified RTP list and the target markets. We log the release in our review tracker with its type and volatility band.
At least three separate sessions on two devices, desktop and mobile portrait. A minimum of 500 base-game spins across two stake levels, and every bonus route triggered or bought where the demo allows. We note pacing, dead spells, feature frequency and anything that confuses.
Every figure in the At a glance box is checked against the rules, the paytable or the certification documents. If a figure cannot be verified, it is published as a placeholder, for example [RTP to confirm], never as a guess.
We compare the game with at least three recent releases of the same type and volatility band. Lobby appeal and feature depth are always judged against what operators already list, not in a vacuum.
The reviewer scores all eight criteria with a written reason for each. A second editor reviews the scores. Where the two differ by more than one point on any criterion, they talk it through and the reason for the final score is recorded.
The studio sees the At a glance specifications only, to correct factual errors. It does not see the copy, the scores or the verdict before publication.
The review goes live with its score, verdict and date. Worth watching verdicts are revisited after 90 days. Every later change is logged at the foot of the review.
What we cannot measure. We test in demo mode, so we do not see real-money player behaviour or a game's live performance in any lobby. Demo results are not predictive of any individual session. Where an operator or studio shares performance data with us, we say so and explain how we used it.
Eight criteria, each scored from 1 to 5. Four belong to the operator lens and carry 60% of the overall score. Four belong to the player lens and carry 40%.
Does the game give players a reason to stay past the first session?
Will it stand out in a crowded lobby?
How easily can it be listed in regulated markets?
Does it fit the audience a lobby actually serves?
Is it fun to play, spin after spin?
Can a player understand what they are playing?
Can everyone play it comfortably?
Does the design respect the player?
How the overall score works. The operator lens average counts for 60% and the player lens average for 40%. The result is rounded to the nearest half point and shown out of 5. The verdict then follows the rules below, including the safety gates, which can override a high total.
Set a score for each criterion and see the overall score and verdict the rules produce. This is the same calculation our editors use.
A strong fit for most lobbies with no gate triggered.
The score sets the starting point. The rules below decide the label, checked in this order.
Any criterion scored 1, or Safer play design scored 2 or lower, means With caveats whatever the total. An overall score below 3 also lands here. The review explains what needs fixing.
Overall 3.5 or higher with Market flexibility at 2 or lower. A well-made game that only works for one market or audience.
Overall 4.5 or higher with no criterion below 4. Qualifying is not enough: the desk chooses at most one Editor’s pick a month, and it must beat that month’s other releases.
Overall 3.75 or higher with no gate triggered. Includes games that qualify for Editor’s pick but were not chosen.
Overall from 3 to below 3.75. Also used for a strong debut from a new studio with no track record. Revisited after 90 days.
The same review serves two readers. Pick yours.
Use the review as a listing brief. Each part answers a question you would ask a studio account manager.
Send the demo link, game sheet, rules, certified RTP list and target markets to news@igamingrepublic.com. Editorial reviews are free and never guaranteed.
Use the review to decide whether a game is your kind of game, before you spend a penny on it.
Gambling should stay entertainment. Set a budget and a time limit before you start, and stop when you reach either. If it stops being fun, help is free and confidential.
We are a trade publication that also sells media. These rules keep the two apart.
Games change after launch. Reviews change with them, in the open.
Our weekly briefing for industry leaders who want fast, accurate and relevant iGaming intelligence. Every Monday morning.