Evolution settles with Black Cube report’s law firm
- Evolution settles its defamation claim against law firm Calcagni & Kanefsky.
- Settlement terms are confidential and Black Cube’s lawyers want to see them.
- A ruling on Black Cube’s dismissal bid will decide whether Playtech can be added.
Evolution has settled its defamation claim against Calcagni & Kanefsky LLP, the New Jersey law firm that sent a Black Cube report on the supplier to US gaming regulators in 2021.
Lawyers for the firm disclosed the deal on November 17, at the start of a hearing in Atlantic County Superior Court.
Terms kept private
The settlement removes the firm from a case Evolution first filed in December 2021. Black Cube, the private intelligence agency that produced the report, is now the only defendant.
Neither side has revealed the terms. Evolution’s lawyers cited confidentiality provisions in court, Casino.org reported. Judge John Porto indicated a court order might be needed to compel their release.
Black Cube’s lawyers have asked to see the agreement. They told the court they believe it includes no financial payment. That has not been independently confirmed.
From report to rival
The report reached regulators in November 2021. Calcagni & Kanefsky sent it to the New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement (DGE) and the Pennsylvania Gaming Control Board.
It claimed Evolution’s games could be accessed in sanctioned countries, including Iran, and in other prohibited markets. Regulators opened investigations and Evolution’s share price fell sharply.
Evolution sued the law firm and its unnamed client the following month for defamation and trade libel. The DGE closed its investigation in February 2024 without taking action. It found no evidence that Evolution knowingly allowed, or materially benefited from, prohibited sales.
For years, nobody knew who was behind the report. The court eventually ordered the law firm to name its author. Evolution then added Black Cube as a defendant on June 11, 2025.
Black Cube was later ordered to name its own client. Court proceedings in October 2025 revealed it was Playtech, and Evolution named its rival publicly soon after.
Evolution says Playtech paid Black Cube more than £1.8m for the work. Playtech rejects the allegations and says it acted in good faith. It has stood by its decision to commission the report.
Its 2025 annual results repeated that position. Playtech classed the dispute as a contingent liability only, noting that no claim had been served on the group.
In April 2026, Evolution asked to add Playtech, PR executive Juda Engelmayer and others as defendants, with claims including fraud and racketeering. Judge Porto refused the request on June 5, without prejudice. He ruled that Black Cube’s dismissal bid had to be decided first.
Black Cube’s case
Black Cube’s bid relies on New Jersey’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act (UPEPA), the state’s anti-SLAPP law. Under the law, defendants can challenge lawsuits they argue aim to punish protected expression.
Black Cube says reporting suspected violations to a regulator is protected activity. It also says its findings are based on genuine evidence. Evolution disputes that evidence. It says the report was a deliberate attempt to damage its reputation and competitive position.
In December 2025, Black Cube filed sworn evidence with the court. This included videos it said showed its staff playing Evolution games in Iran as recently as May 2025.
The two sides have also clashed over disclosure. Judge Porto granted a request from Strategy UK Ltd, the company behind the Black Cube assignment, ordering Evolution to hand over its communications with US regulators.
Evolution later accused Black Cube of withholding details of payments made after 2021. Judge Porto declined to penalize the agency, finding it had answered the original request reasonably.
Black Cube’s latest dismissal filing cites two documents from this year. The first is the Spectrum report, a review Evolution commissioned itself and Black Cube filed in court on September 8.
Spectrum’s VPN tests found Evolution games available in prohibited jurisdictions including the UAE, Singapore, Hong Kong and Saudi Arabia. The report also acknowledged that Evolution did not knowingly allow its games in prohibited territories.
In a September 9 regulatory announcement, Playtech said the report corroborates fundamental aspects of Black Cube’s investigation. It pointed to concerns about game availability in certain prohibited markets and a lack of proactive monitoring of Evolution’s customers.
The second is Evolution’s £4.75m settlement with the UK Gambling Commission, which Evolution announced on July 15. The regulator’s public statement followed on July 23. It found Evolution games had appeared on six unlicensed websites run by two operators and accessible to consumers in Great Britain.
What the judge decides
Judge Porto’s UPEPA ruling is now the decision that matters. Black Cube is pursuing it through an order to show cause.
If Black Cube wins, Evolution’s claims against it could be dismissed, at least those covered by the challenge. UPEPA requires the court to award costs and attorney’s fees to a defendant that succeeds on its order to show cause.
If Evolution wins, it can renew its attempt to add Playtech. The supplier also plans to make a fresh request to add Engelmayer once the UPEPA question is settled.
That could leave a London-listed supplier answering Evolution’s claims directly in a US court. Black Cube’s push to see the settlement terms is still open, and Judge Porto has indicated it may take a court order to release them.
Do you have a story worth sharing?
Send it over to our editors!